Grammar The Pitfalls of Trying to Sound Smart |
The Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation

The Pitfalls of Trying to Sound Smart

Most people tend to view themselves as having at least average intelligence. While few consider themselves exceptionally intelligent, many believe they’re smarter than the average person.

This presents an interesting contradiction: If most people believe they’re above average, obviously, most cannot actually be above average.

Both Mark Twain and Abraham Lincoln have been attributed for saying that “it is better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and remove all doubt.”

We can find a related thought in Proverbs 17:28: “Even a fool, when he holdeth his peace, is counted wise.”

Although such axioms encompass more than mere grammatical error, they still comprise the idea that when we write or speak, our minds are on display.

Many of us have heard or read people using words and expressions they believe make them sound smart. Instead, they convey the opposite impression through misplaced confidence.

Some people will at times use big words (or too many words), elaborate expressions, and overly formal language to assert a proper intellect. Along the way, we may have even been one of those people (or we still are).

We can all benefit from noting the difference between communicating intelligently and trying to sound intelligent. Where the former demonstrates clarity of understanding, the latter may reveal a desire to influence, without having done our homework, how others perceive us.

We’ve all made mistakes in writing or speaking. We also have the ability to learn what we’ve mistaken and grow in our informed linguistic accuracy.

To that end, we’ll look at some common ways we may try to sound smart but miss the mark.

Note that not all unconventional forms of expression are wrong. Some are accepted informality, and others are still increasingly accepted as our language evolves. Our usage also can change over time. Our goal here is to identify genuine errors.

When Proper English Goes Wrong: Hypercorrection

Hypercorrection is the mistaken application of a perceived rule of grammar, pronunciation, or usage.

It will often happen in an attempt to sound more educated or speak more correctly because we’re trying to avoid a widely perceived mistake. Instead, we overapply a rule, producing an incorrect or unnatural result.

For example, we may do this with incorrect cases of pronouns.

Incorrect Correct Correct: Reason Why
between you and I between you and me The pronouns are prepositional objects.
Me and Wayne can go Wayne and I can go The pronoun is a subject; it’s also better form to refer to oneself last.
Whom is speaking? Who is speaking? The pronoun is a subject (whom is an object).
It’s for Jane or myself It’s for Jane or me The pronoun is objective (not reflexive).

Sometimes, communicating as if we’re well read, we might use a word but mean a similar one.

Word Used Do We Mean?
bemused (puzzled, confused) amused (entertained)
decimate (large reduction, something left) obliterate (total destruction, nothing left)
ironic (marked by contrast of expectation and reality) coincidental (occurring by chance without planning)
disinterested (not having personal bias or interest) uninterested (not interested)
nonplussed (confused, bewildered) unfazed (not surprised or unsettled)
averse (having a strong dislike) adverse (unfavorable, harmful)
farther (physical distance) further (figurative distance, to a greater extent)
lie (to recline, rest) lay (to put or place)

As we’ve suggested, as language evolves, what once may have been called incorrect can weave its way into daily acceptance.

One such example is the word enormity. Traditionally, its meaning has been “an outrageous or improper act; monstrous wickedness.” Today, however, it is almost always used to convey “the quality or state of being huge” (enormousness). Such use has become so prevalent that more references and style authorities are accepting it.

When Proper English Goes Wrong: Big Words, Wrong Phrases

In addition to using the wrong pronoun or choice from similar words, when we want to sound smart we might dig for really big words to display the room for them in our intellects.

Big Word Why Not?   Big Word Why Not?
commence begin mitigate reduce
obfuscate confuse discombobulate confuse
facilitate help incontrovertible undeniable
elucidate explain fortuitous lucky
expeditious quick mendacious dishonest
ameliorate improve pusillanimous cowardly
recalcitrant stubborn magnanimous generous

Then we have words that we might unnecessarily lengthen or complicate.

Big Word Real Word
conversate converse
orientate orient
incentivize encourage, motivate

We might also double up on words that mean the same thing, creating a tautology.

added bonus close proximity advance planning
final outcome revert back consensus of opinion
past history end result free gift

Let us not forget malformed phrases.

Wrong Phrase Right Word Reason
is comprised of comprises Comprise means consist of or include.
a myriad of myriad, many Myriad is an adjective (not a noun).

Writing to Sound Smart: What Research Says

The ability to express a complicated idea in simple, precise language is often a better indication of intelligence than the ability to dress up a simple idea in complicated language. 

Research supports this. A Princeton University study published in 2006 in Applied Cognitive Psychology found that writers who unnecessarily used complex vocabulary were often perceived as less intelligent than those who communicated the same ideas in simpler language.

The negative effect occurred even when the underlying quality of the writing was held constant. Making text harder to read could negatively affect perceptions of the writer as well.

More recently, a 2024 study (“Reading Dies in Complexity: Online News Consumers Prefer Simple Writing”) examined more than 30,000 field experiments involving headlines from The Washington Post and Upworthy. The study found that:

readers were more likely to click on simpler headlines

readers paid more attention to simpler language

readers demonstrated better recognition and retention of simpler headlines

professional writers did not exhibit the same preference for simpler headlines as general readers did

These findings suggest that simplicity isn’t merely a stylistic preference. It can influence whether people engage with content, where they direct their attention, and what they remember.

Misunderstood Concepts of Modern English

English, and perhaps any other language for that matter, gives us an established tradition to uphold. Although it changes and updates itself with passing time and generations, it includes principles we perceive as ironclad and are willing to defend.

In certain cases, our defense may have proper intent yet identify us as cemented in edicts long since passed. The following are some grammatical concepts we might cling to although they have expired among the masses.

Misconception Reality
Never end a sentence with a preposition. Ending a sentence with a preposition is fine.
Never split an infinitive. Split infinitives are grammatically acceptable.
You can’t start a sentence with and or but. You can.
You can’t use they as singular. You can, unless it creates confusion.

In the end, our goal is to communicate—not to sound smart. If we consider our audience and write or speak to it properly, the audience will decide for themselves whether we may be smart.

And that, in the end, is how intelligence rises without having to be lifted.

If the article or the existing discussions do not address a thought or question you have on the subject, please use the "Comment" box at the bottom of this page.

Leave a Comment or Question:

Please ensure that your question or comment relates to the topic of the blog post. Unrelated comments may be deleted. If necessary, use the "Search" box on the right side of the page to find a post closely related to your question or comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *